Capri

You’d never expect to find such a nice restaurant tucked away behind the Wal-mat on Keystone, but Capri (a member of Indianapolis Originals, so bonuis points to start with) is a great way to get your Italian fix. The decor is warm, there’s a large fireplace in the bar, and a recent patio additionwould make for a lovely evening dinign al fresco. With a location close to Keystone at the Crossing, Chris guessed that “a lot of power lunches happen here”, and the atmosphere has that dark-wood-yellow-wall rich sort of feel to it. Staff is excellent with wine reccomendations, and we enjoyed glasses of merlot and cabernet. It was a cool rain late summer afternoon, so reds seemed appropriate.

Chris ordered and loved the pollo con salsiccia (chicken with sausage). The rosemary was excellent, and who doesn’t love italian sausage? My pasta, penetta boscaiola, was penne, tomatoes, and portabella mushrooms—very fresh, very light, and just what i wanted. It just takes a look at Capri’s menu to see that they cater to many tastes. Several meatless entrees make this a very vegetarian-friendly menu, and the offerings go from spicy to beefy to light to creamy.

In our never-ending quest to find the city’s best tiramisu (sigh…still looking…we’ll just have to keep ordering dessert), we were pleased but not convinced. We may have to try it again, just to make sure. And we probably will. Although Chris did bring his parents back to Capri for a repeat visit, he regrettably forgot what they ordered. This may be because they returned home to find nine inches of water in the basement (it was a dark and story night) but at least they had some carbs to work off…

Dunaway’s Palazzo Ossigeno Restaurant

This was a birthday dinner, so we wanted to make it something special. After trying to finish our wedge salads, we really didn’t need to have dinner, but I ordered the quail. The accompanying goat cheese polenta alone was worth it, but the sauteed greens and the quali itself was wonderful (once you get past the fact that you’re eating teeny little birds). Chris chose Arrogant Bastard Ale (partly because it was fun to order, and partly because it was really, really good) and the pistachio-crusted chicken, which he also enjoyed immensely. We can only image how good the creme brulee must be, because the couple next to us seemed to enjoy theirs quite a bit. The decor, the service and the food were all high quality, and even though we were seated way too close to other diners to feel like we were having an intimate and romantic dinner, we still enjoyed the meal.

Puccini’s Smiling Teeth

I’d heard so many good things from other people about this place; Chris has enjoyed it in the past and enjoyed his chicken marsala. They used sweet marsala, however, and the carmelization of the onions made it almost too sweet. Delicious, though. My pomodoro was average…nothing too special. It’s a shame I make myself order the “healthy” dishes and don’t let myself get something with multiple cheese or sausage. Everything smelled good and with the exception of the weird lady sitting at the booth next to us, everyone was very friendly and smily for a Tuesday night.

Amici

We cannot eat here enough! It’s a Lockerbie Square Italian favorite. Romantic (but cold) old building, steaming crusty bread, and excellent house Merlot. The entrees come either carnivore or herbivore-style with crisp veggies, zesty sauce, and stringy cheese—just right for a comfy dinner on a cold night. The selections of pasta with garden vegetables and the linguini with Italian sausage are our favorites. The fettuccini and gorgonzola is good, but becomes monotonous halfway through. We think it could use something to break up the texture a bit. All said, we love this place!

Maggiano’s Little Italy

Raucous, yet surprisingly romantic dinner event. Go with a slew of friends and family, and order family style, it’s an orgy of food and wine. Make reservations early, the good times can book up weeks in advance. This is by far one of our favorites (although again, regrettably, a chain).