Mezza Luna

We returned here recently after more than two years, and it seems to have gotten even better. Last time I remember having The Chip…so good (pasta in a smoky chipotle cream sauce) that it made that much of a lasting impression. This time I opted for the pasta primavera and the vegetables were just crisp enough and the pasta had this foreign delicious sauce on it (butter, ha!) Chris went for his standard choice, eggplant parmesan. He enjoyed it, too (I think he might have wanted more cheese), and although I have a hard time with Italian restaurants that serve mashed potatoes, these were garlicky and nasty (good nasty) and delicious. Nasty, too, was the appetizer bread (although we came this close to ordering the calamari) and the side salad was pretty decent, expect for the typical Indiana tomatoes.

All in all, I’m glad we went back. It was warm and toasty (the fire was going), dark and romantic, and my Cosmopolitan gave me that fuzzy feeling that makes me want to play footsie under the table. Nice dinner.

Illinois Street Food Emporium

This bustling neighborhood bakery and deli serves everything from healthy sprouts and tomatoes on grainy bread to tall mousse cakes with chocolate shavings resembling Beyoncés hair. The turkey, bacon, and avocado croissant was an instant favorite with us. Vegetable soup was hearty and perfect for a rainy day (and I bet it would have been good even if it had been sunny). While seemingly a perfect spot for a Sunday brunch, they unfortunately do not serve this meal. Whole desserts are available for take-out, however, so you can still get your fix.

Broad Ripple Brewpub

Grilled entrees and surprisingly decent pub fare, including Scotch eggs (read: hard-boiled eggs rolled in bacon and fried in fat…can you say heart attack in a convenient dumpling shape?). Beer brewed on premises is great on a summer evening. Even our Scottish friend enjoyed herself. She tried buffalo for the first time, Chris went for bangers and mash and I ended up with a veggie burger and veggie crisps (sweet potatoes and taro instead of regular potatoes makes for some nice variety). The Jenny-style pasta is very good as well, so this goes beyond standard burgers and fries.

Some Guys Pizza, Pasta, Grill

This busy, upbeat pizza and pasta restaurant lies at the east end of Broad Ripple. Their brick oven churns out perfectly-crusted (if you’re into the whole thin-crust thing) pizzas with toppings ranging from traditional to on pizza?! and pasta dishes frosted with gooey toasted mozzarella.

For all the times we’ve visited Some Guys and enjoyed multiple permutations of ravioli, tortellini, tomato-vodka sauce and such, we only recently tried the pizza, leaving that arena to Bazbeaux, Broad Ripple’s “other” gourmet pizza haven. We’re hooked now, and proud to declare that there the winner is not either restaurant, but the diners. Emily enjoyed the primavera pizza, but I found it slightly oiler than I would have preferred. We’ve heard the Thai chicken pizza is good as well, however I’m going to have to work up to that: I’m a pizza traditionalist. Only in the last few years have I opened my mind enough to accept anything but the thickest, deepest, sausagiest Chicago-style cholesterol-fest pizza.

Since their excellent pizza was a new experience for us, the pasta selections are obviously what has kept us coming back. I really can’t decide which they do better. If you’re lucky, you’ll visit on one of the rare days when they have lasagna available.

I love me a good wood oven. During our last visit, Emily and I announced to each other that our next house will have two such massive wood ovens: one in the kitchen, and one on the deck near the pool that friends and neighbors can use. This would be after we win the lottery, of course. Which in turn would be after we begin playing, and that is unlikely.

Some Guys serves good beer (Bell’s Oberon in the summer, Blue Moon, Peroni, etc), and wine, as well. The latter packs quite a punch if you haven’t eaten in the eight hours prior to your dining experience. Best to wait on that Roma bread (yeah, get the Roma bread. It’s garlicky nirvana) before getting too far through your Chianti.

Desserts aren’t to be missed, either. Tiramisu and carrot cake have finished off more than one pleasant meal in the past.

The wait staff is quite a bit friendlier and easy-going than average, though they do stay quite busy in the confines of the densely-packed restaurant. This is a restaurant we would happily recommend to all walks of life for any happy occasion.

Union Jack Pub

Though under the same ownership as the Aristocrat and the Elbow Room, Union Jack’s doesn’t quite measure up. The menu boasts nothing above standard pub fare (read: mostly fried) but the atmosphere is casual and fun.

Yats

YATS WILL KILL YOU. But oh my lord, what a great way to go. $5 (no chump change!) buys you a heaping plate of rice and your favorite selection of the day with a side of garlic bread. Daily offerings vary, but count on seeing étouffée, red beans and rice, spinach and mushrooms, etc. There’s almost always something vegetarian available. Can’t decide? Get a split plate for a buck extra. Also try the downtown location on Massachusetts Ave. The owner, Joe Vuscovich, is something of a local icon.

Shalimar Indian Restaurant

Rtandard Indian cuisine with a weekday lunch buffet worthy of a big, fat nap afterwards. There’s always a coupon in the Nuvo, look for it. Caters well to vegetarians

The Parthenon

Good Greek food in the heart of Broad Ripple. Not only do their (vegetarian) dolmades and pasticchio rank highly, they have belly dancers for your entertainment. As if the saganaki (flaming cheese) wasn’t entertaining enough…

The Red Key Tavern

Right around the corner, as local as it gets. But I wish I liked the place better. They make fun of you if a) you don’t order beer and b) you order an import. No Guinness?!

Aristocrat Pub

Pages and pages of menu options offer something for everyone, from huge dinner salads and unique pasta dishes to sandwiches and steaks. Great Sunday brunch offers omelettes and those really yummy cheesy potatoes.